Topic Index
Who would win in WoW

Username:Password:
Log In
Adventurer
Posts: 264
Joined: 10 May 2009

this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

thank you, and i hope i can get some replies :D

Ben

Power Leveler
Posts: 4214
Joined: 12 Feb 2009

Sorry but the only names I recongnize are Thrall,Proudmoore,Sunstride,and Arthas.

Power Leveler
Posts: 4166
Joined: 30 Oct 2008

Thrall, Jaina, Uther, Archimonde.

As for the last one; do you mean Orcish Horde or the New Horde from World of Warcraft?

The Orcish Horde would be absolutely decimated by the combined forces of the Night Elves, Humans, Gnomes, Dwarves, and those big purple things that should never have entered the milieu.

Master Looter
Posts: 1395
Joined: 20 Mar 2008

From what I know about Warcraft lore, some of these fights would be extremely easy because of a simple reason: Thrall and Jaina are the only ones alive.
But assuming they're all alive.

1) Gromm Hellscream would win, he drank Mannoroth's blood absorbing some of his power to kill Cenarius and later killed Mannoroth after Thrall failed.
2) It depends on which Kael'thas. Before the sunwell was destroyed, Jaina wouldn't have a chance but after it's destruction, Jaina would probably win.
3) Uther would win. He's more powerful than Arthas, who was only able to beat defeat him with Frostmourne.
4) Archimonde wins, the Night Elves had to sacrifice their source of immortality to kill him, which IIRC also left their most powerful druid comatose.
5) Horde is physically stronger but the Alliance has technology. I'd go with the Alliance because in a war, I prefer to be on the side that has tanks and guns.

Master Looter
Posts: 1408
Joined: 27 Feb 2009

Aren't there any invincible npc's? :p

Looking For Group
Posts: 154
Joined: 10 Apr 2009

1. Thrall
2. Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer
4. Illidan Stormrage
5 FOR THE HORDE ALLIANCE SCUM!!!

-Sincerely unconcerned, SB-

Power Leveler
Posts: 3846
Joined: 21 Feb 2008

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

Firstly, you're not posting on the Escapist, you're posting on War Cry, this forum is mirrored on the Escapist at the moment, but is not actually part of it.

Secondly, this is your first post? You can do better than this surely?

Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 799
Joined: 11 Jan 2009

I agree, Thrall then Sunstride.
The rest, don't matter.

Master Looter
Posts: 2014
Joined: 14 Jan 2009

Grom Hellscream, hes a crazy ass orc.

Woo

Master Looter
Posts: 2532
Joined: 15 Jan 2009

Grom
Jaina
Uther
Archimonde
No answer

Thats what I think.

Uh oh, you had better call the Waaaahmbulance!

Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 638
Joined: 8 May 2009

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

thank you, and i hope i can get some replies :D

Ben

1. grom, thrall is a little wuss, we already saw this.
2. kael'thas, jaina needs to go back to the kitchen.
3. uther, arthas is so emo he'd hurt himself in the process.
4. illidan, because he's the best bad guy ever.
5. alliance, horde can gtfo.

Undead Army 4 life.

Master Looter
Posts: 2580
Joined: 6 Sep 2008

1. Thrall
2. Jaina, just taking a guess but I always thought it was either her or Rhonin as the strongest mage on Azeroth.
3. Uther definately
4. In terms of power Archi. In terms of kicking ass, Illidan
5. LOK'TAR OGAR! Rise up sons of the Horde!

Master Looter
Posts: 1874
Joined: 26 Oct 2008

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream:Gromm would win easy.just a well known fact
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride:Kael'thas.
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend:Uther was Arthas's trainer so saying that Arthas would win means that you have no genral knowledge of Warcraft.
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde:Archimonde.
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P):HORDE FTW

Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 826
Joined: 17 Apr 2008

Alliance (just because they have dwarves).

Master Looter
Posts: 1415
Joined: 18 Mar 2009

thrall, jaina, Arthas if it's the arthas with frostmourne
if arthas doesn't have frostmourne yet it's uther.
and illidan because both he and his weapons are more awesome then archimonde.
finally alliance

Adventurer
Posts: 462
Joined: 24 Feb 2009

benbenthegamerman:

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

1. Grom would probably win that one.
2. Kael'Thas, simply because I don't like Jaina. I know Jaina is supposed to be very powerful, but...Kael'Thas is so much more interesting.
3. Uther. Arthas is nothing without Frostmourne against Uther.
4. Archimonde
5. Alliance. Why? I'm Alliance. That's why.

Adventurer
Posts: 287
Joined: 2 Sep 2008

1. Grom - Thrall is a Visionary not a warrior
2. Kael'Thas because Jaina is all for peace not war
3. Uther - hes a legendary Paladin and Arthas was merely a Paladin in training
4. Illidan - he has the powers of Sargaras and Gul'dan
5. Horde - even though I like the Alliance, the Horde has the Forsaken - unless we are talking about the old horde

Dungeon Crawler
Posts: 814
Joined: 3 Jul 2009

1) Thrall
2) Jaina
3) Uther
4) Illidan
5) Horde baby

Ding! (Grats!)
Posts: 29
Joined: 17 Jul 2009

Thrall vs. Grom Hellscream would be epic but as to who would win i have no idea. I dont reconize the other names but i do know the HORDE OWNS THE ALLIANCE. When was the last time horde lost a bg.

Apprentice
Posts: 5
Joined: 25 Jul 2009

1. Thrall Even if grom has bloodpact Thrall is still a very powerful shaman
2. Kael'thas Sunstride Jaina is a talanted mage but is can hardly be called one of the most powerful the same applies for Rhonin
3. Uther the Lightbringer Was almost able to beat Arthas W/ frostmourne but was eventually defeated
4. Archimonde No question
5. No answer

Apprentice
Posts: 9
Joined: 16 Jul 2009

Grom
Kael'thas
Uther
Archimond
neither because i love the Horde but my mains an Ally

Killed 10 Boars
Posts: 11
Joined: 30 Jul 2009

Now to be honest. Im alliance and when faction change comes out you can bet im using it ok now to the question.

1. Grom Hellscream (but hes dead so thrall technicly! but if alive grom)
2. Kael'thas Sunstride (Jaina is unexperienced shes just another portal vendor taxi)
3. Uther the light bringer (Arthas wasnt much of a fighter before becoming LK)
4. Illidan Stormrage (Archimonde Couldnt beat a few Poxy Druids over The world tree no matter the allmighty pimp)
5. Horde on most servers. (Alliance Are mainly children and have no plans of stratergys thought out to even have a chance to defeat the hordes efforts)

Master Looter
Posts: 2532
Joined: 15 Jan 2009

nilcypher:

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

Firstly, you're not posting on the Escapist, you're posting on War Cry, this forum is mirrored on the Escapist at the moment, but is not actually part of it.

Secondly, this is your first post? You can do better than this surely?

I know I can do better, but don't call me Sherley.

=)

Uh oh, you had better call the Waaaahmbulance!

Looking For Group
Posts: 190
Joined: 1 Aug 2009

1. Thrall
2. Kael'thas Sunstrider
3. Uther the Lightbringer
4. Archimonde
5. Alliance (Thrall is a green pussy while Varian is AWESOME.)

Uther would beat Arthas' skull in, no competiton.

Arthas was just an angsty virgin.

Master Looter
Posts: 1641
Joined: 5 Mar 2008

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

thank you, and i hope i can get some replies :D

Ben

1. Grom would win. The way I see it, Grom's son almost defeated Thrall if it wasnt for the Scourge attack on Orgimmar. And I think Grom mustve been even stronger than Garrosh.

2. Thats a tough one. But im leaning towards Kaelthas due to his fel infused abilities and general combat experience.

3. You mean Arthas before he became a death knight? Uther would school his ass.

4. Illidan without a doubt.

5. I know your not supposed to guess an outcome.

Ding! (Grats!)
Posts: 29
Joined: 23 Jul 2009

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

thank you, and i hope i can get some replies :D

Ben

1. Grom. Grom was a total maniac on the battlefield. Just play Warcraft 2.
2. Jaina. Kael'thas was just a pretender who abdicated his rightful place on the throne to seek power. Let's not forget that Jaina was Antonidas' student, and I don't think Kael'thas could begin to match Antonidas in a fight.
3. Uther. He was a famous paladin, and one of the best. Arthas was his student, and was just beginning to embrace the way of the paladin. Uther just has plain experience over Arthas.
4. Archimonde. It would be fair to say that Illidan, the Demon-Hunter could match Archimonde in a fight, but Archimonde was a grand warlock that could bend the Nether's energies to his will. In all fairness, I think the fight would leave both of them dead.
5. Horde. From a neutral point of view, the Horde is much more stable than the Alliance. The Noble Houses of Stormwind are laden with corruption, the Night Elves are dying, the Dwarfs have been steadily losing ground, and the Gnomes, well... who's ever taken the Gnomes seriously. That leaves the Draenei who seem more or less, dedicated to the end. The Horde is held together by the Orcs and Darkspear Trolls who, since the first war have been indivisible. That's all the horde needs. They are aided by the Tauren, who would never splinter from the Horde, the Forsaken, who possess most of the territory of Lordaeron, and the Blood Elves, who by and large are the residents and keepers of Quel'thalas.

Þá kvað þat Heimdallr, hvítastr ása,vissi hann vel fram sem vanir aðrir: "Bindum vér Þór þá brúðar líni, hafi hann it mikla men Brísinga."

In short, it involves Norse cross-dressing.

I'a Cthulhu! I'a Yog-Sothoth! I'a Nyarlathotep! Glory to the Old Ones!

Ding! (Grats!)
Posts: 33
Joined: 3 Aug 2009

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream = Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride = Jaina
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend = Uther
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde = Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P) = FOR THE ALLIANCE!

Killed 10 Boars
Posts: 16
Joined: 4 Aug 2009

FOR THE HORDE

The war between horde and alliance has been push back because of the burning legion and now arthas - WoTlK storyline is fantastic but please dont forget about killin alliance.

Ding! (Grats!)
Posts: 33
Joined: 3 Aug 2009

Its all about killing the blood elves

Killed 10 Boars
Posts: 24
Joined: 8 Jun 2009

benbenthegamerman:
this is my first post on the escapist, and im going to talk from my heart and soul: World of Warcraft.
this is a simple who would win contest. all i do is post the NPCs and you send who would win. AND AWAAAAAAAY we go!

1. Thrall or Grom Hellscream
2. Jaina Proudmoore or Kael'thas Sunstride
3. Uther the Lightbringer or Arthas Menethil before coming to northrend
4. Illidan Stormrage or Archimonde
5. Alliance or Horde (choose horde or die :P)

thank you, and i hope i can get some replies :D

Ben

Grom Hellscream, based on the fact that he was stronger than Thrall was, and it took Thrall seeing his brother Die at the hand of [insert name of the demon] to gain the strength to defeat him.

Kael'thas, Jaina is too passive minded, yeah shes a great magician, but Kael'thas is a more badass mage. He thinks remoreslessly and would easily kill her where she would show mercy.

If i have to consider pre northrend Arthas, then Uther would win. He was his superior in both power and skill.

If you give Archimonde the powers he had in Warcraft3, then Archimonde would win. As he would shatter the Skull of Gul'dan which would take away Illidan's demonic form. Then all he would have left is his demon hunter/night elf abilities.

And... Neither would win. Thrall of the orcs while tribal and very power oriented, is wise and wisdom would see past all war. The druids would seek peace through the Cenarian enclaves communicating with the tauren and night elves. The humans would see great losses at the hand of the more aggressive horde, and likely they would want to talk peace before more people die.

image

Master Looter
Posts: 1493
Joined: 3 Dec 2008

1.Grom
2.Kael'thas in my mind this wouldn't even be a competition
3.not sure I'd say Uther but it'd be a pretty boring fight
4. Even demonic Illidan no matter how awesome he is would never beat Archimonde
5. I'm gonna go horde, just due to the undead; much easier to replenish your army if you can use the bodies of your allies/enemies. If just using them for food

Master Looter
Posts: 1314
Joined: 19 Jun 2009

1. Thrall
2. Kaelthas
3. Arthas
4. Illidan
5. Alliance (lets not forget we were all alliance fighting horde in the rps and they added the horde for the mmo so you dont have just 1 option and to make it more fun! plus im boring and would rather have humans rule Azeroth)

If life gives you lemons,squeeze the them like a madman!

Killed 10 Boars
Posts: 18
Joined: 4 Aug 2009

headshotcatcher:
Aren't there any invincible npc's? :p

Thrall.
He pwns all.

(Successful convert to Horde by my friends.)

Lok'Tar O'gar!

Adventurer
Posts: 461
Joined: 3 Apr 2009

Grom
Jaina
Uther
Archimonde, Even though he basically got killed by a peasant rush
Horde

All there is,
All there will be,
in my stomach,
surely digesting

 
Topic Index

Reply to Thread

You must be logged in to post.
Username:  
Password:  
  

Not registered? Sign up for a free account!

Forum Jump: