Dungeons And Dragons Online: 1Up Review of DDO

Clocking in at a score of 6.5, the 1Up review starts with:

The good news about the unwieldy named Dungeons & Dragons Online: Stormreach is that the developer, Turbine, has managed to shoehorn most of the equally unwieldy D&D rules into the game. The bad news: Turbine managed to shoehorn most of those unwieldy rules into the game. The end result is an online game that is a fairly faithful adaptation of its pen-and-paper source but is also less than the sum of its (very) considerable parts.

Their main complaints seem to be the lack of "organic" groups that would be found offline in conjunction with the questing system. See the rest of their opinion of DDO here.